1000

Click here to edit subtitle

Blog

Am I A Pelagianist? (Do We Earn God's Love?)

Posted by thethousandmarch on August 17, 2014 at 5:55 PM

I was drinking from my son’s Mickey Mouse cup the other night and it prompted my daughter to tell me that she had decided for her birthday that she would have Pony (My Little Pony) cups for the girls and Mickey cups for the boys. This may seem like a trivial thing, but it’s moments like this that give me great joy. In them I see an expression, no matter how small, of my daughter’s individuality. She is expressing her desires – by expressing her choice she is exercising her freedom, and is expressing her separateness from me and the rest of the universe. Though she is in part my creation I enjoy seeing her be her own being – creating her own story. Of course this also gives me a certain amount of anxiety as I think of the things I can’t protect her from, but I would not choose safety over the beauty of freedom. Is the Creator so different that he would not receive joy in giving his creation freedom – self-determining freedom?

 

For Christians questions such as this can lead to a debate which boils down to who is ultimately responsible for saving the individual; God, or the individual themselves. For the classical Calvinist if the individual is capable of accepting or rejecting God’s offer of salvation then it is ultimately up to the individual to save themselves and in this they are saved by a work they have done. So even though a good Calvinist will say we have free will, they believe God chooses some people to save and gives them a special measure of grace which so changes their desires they will freely (but without exception) choose God. Those who do not receive this irresistible grace freely choose to reject God. But it’s important to understand that the chosen are not simply given the ability to have faith in God, they are given faith in God, and therefore even their faith is not a thing which is recognized as deserving of reward.

 

Now one of the accusations which a Calvinist will level at non-Calvinists (the rest of us are not all Armenians) is that we are Pelagianists, or at least a semi-Pelagianists. Pelagianism is the belief that original sin did not taint human nature and that mortal will is still capable of choosing good or evil without special divine aid. In other words human nature is good and humans who choose to do good will earn eternal life as a reward for their own good work. This means we need not rely upon the grace and mercy of God to save us from the corruption of sin and death. Semi-Pelagianism would be the belief that we need Jesus to help us, but we still have to do some of the work. And it is our will-power, boosted by the fuel of grace no doubt, which has the ability to empower that work – Jesus opens the door, but we have to walk through it. Of course most Christians don’t go running around calling themselves Pelagianists, but I’d agree with the Calvinists that most Christians are semi-Pelagianists, or dangerously close to it. It is natural to our corrupted nature. We like to think that despite the evidence most of us are basically good (certainly I am) and as long as we give it our best shot God will take care of the rest, because he owes it to us.


I believe we have a somehow self-determined choice to respond positively or negatively to the work of God’s Spirit in our lives; though I don’t believe the will has much of anything to do with this choice. I believe that freedom is one of the most important things God has built into the creation. I also believe that humans as created beings are full of God’s goodness. And I believe there are non-Christians who God counts as righteous, who will therefore live in his presence eternally. So am I a Pelagianist, or Semi-Pelagianist? No.

 

Humans are good, we are amazing, we are created in God’s image and we each individually bear a special worth because of this no matter how corrupted by sin we are. However we are all corrupted by the condition of sin, and as a result we will all die. Therefore we are all in need of saving. And here is where we really come to the difference between many people (who may be called Pelagianists) and myself. I’m not relying on the goodness of humans, even as good as some of us may be, to be the reason God will save any of us. I’m certainly not relying upon my goodness. I’m relying on the goodness, mercy, grace, and love of God. Yes God is also just and justice must be served; there can be no redemption without justice. But God will redeem many people and situations we think are unredeemable. So it is not faith in the goodness of humans, or our ability to earn anything from God based upon our good works that gives me hope. It is not man’s will that I think is powerful. In the Bible I see a God revealed who wants to save people and I don’t think he’s holding anything back.

 

Categories: Basic Christian Belief, Grace, Parenting

Post a Comment

Oops!

Oops, you forgot something.

Oops!

The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.

Already a member? Sign In

299 Comments

Reply JamesClots
2:59 AM on December 10, 2017 
chat sex chat sex strip club webcam free sex chat assignment help review research writing research paper connect online homework essay helper research essay essay helper essay prompts payday bad credit loan payday bad credit loan payday loans bad credit payday loans for bad credit webcam sluts webcam masturbation webcam sluts free webcam sex quick loans 100 approval cash advance no credit check quick loans 100 approval installment loans no credit check advance cash payday loan cash advance loan cash advance loan loan cash same day payday loans online payday loans no credit check same day payday loans online quick cash loan small online payday loans payday loans for bad credit small online payday loans internet payday loans direct lender payday loans direct lender payday loans easy payday loan direct lender payday loans
Reply JamesClots
7:28 AM on December 9, 2017 
research writing social studies homework help motivating students to do homework research report demystifying dissertation writing university of texas essays essay writing service do math homework for me research essay assignment help melbourne electrical engineering assignment help research report good chat rooms webcam masturbation webcam dildo webcam sluts free webcam sex chat free webcam sex free webcam sex chat free webcam sex romans homework help do my math homework for me college essay writer college essay sex chat chatgirl free web cam sex chat sex research paper buy essay online buy essay online buy essay girls chat free adult sex chat free sex cam chat fuck show to do my homework writing my essay writing my essay writing my essay
Reply Best Payday Loan
11:42 AM on December 8, 2017 
payday loan online advance cash payday loan payday loan advance cash payday loan
Reply Money Loan
3:52 AM on December 7, 2017 
payday advance loan payday loans online payday loans no credit check payday loan
Reply FrankJig
11:03 AM on December 6, 2017 
зарегистрировать домен в зоне москва - хостинг сайтов украина, хостинг сайтов с php и mysql бесплатно.
Reply AbbaLeElilk
7:45 AM on December 6, 2017 
Хлеб. Рецепты хлеба, закваски, теста:
Отрубной хлеб в хлебопечке,
Лаваш. Лучшие рецепты лаваша!,
Закваска для хлеба. Все рецепты заквасок для выпечки хлеба,
Ржаной хлеб — Лучшие рецепты ржаного хлеба для хлебопечки!,
Как приготовить дрожжи из хмеля. ТОП-7 рецептов!,
Ржаной хлеб на закваске. Лучшие рецепты!.
Reply Josephcek
11:00 AM on December 5, 2017 
Klass petrovieski
sitegood3.com
Reply Loans
1:21 AM on December 4, 2017 
loan cash payday loans online emergency loans no credit check payday loan
Reply TERCam
8:43 PM on December 3, 2017 
Повна назва: Агенція протидії корупції
наша місія :Боротьба та запобігання корупції, формування культури неприйнятності корупції, посилення потенціалу суспільства,
ппосилення прозорості серед органів державної влади та сприяння залученню населення до процесів прийняття рішень.

Національне антикорупційне бюро


Знешкодити та запобігти

Знешкодити та запобігти

Національне антикорупційне бюро

Національне антикорупційне бюро

новости Национального бюро

Знешкодити та запобігти
Противодействие коррупции

Уголовная политика Европейского союза в сфере противодействия

Всё о коррупции
Reply PamClots
8:04 PM on December 3, 2017 
online loan small online payday loans easy online payday loans payday advance online advance payday loans best payday loan best payday loan online best payday loans online payday loans for bad credit instant payday loans online payday loans for bad credit bad credit payday loans
Reply JoeClots
9:58 AM on December 3, 2017 
payday loans online direct lenders payday loans online more same day payday loans online
Reply PamClots
10:30 PM on December 2, 2017 
term paper do my math homework school papers school papers college admission essay college admission essay high school geometry homework help custom dissertation writing buy essays buy essays buy essays buy essays online payday advance online online payday loans payday advance online advance payday loans online money lender no credit check best payday loan online direct lenders online loans payday loan online fetish cams free sex cams webcam slut slut cams no credit check payday loans instant approval online payday loans instant approval online payday loan instant approval online payday loan instant approval
Reply JamesClots
8:58 AM on December 1, 2017 
buy an essay buy an essay buy essay online buy essay buy essay online buy an essay science homework help ks3 buy an essay same day loan no credit check payday loans instant approval payday lenders direct advance cash payday loan free sex web cams adult cam adult webcam free sex chat college essay writer essay helper buy an essay essay writer payday loan direct lenders payday loan direct lenders direct payday loan lenders payday loan direct lenders a payday loan fast payday loan cash loan payday advance loan payday advance loan easiest payday loan to get payday loan direct lender payday loan lenders easy approval payday loans 15 minute loans direct lenders easy approval payday loans direct payday lenders online how to write a term paper how to write a term paper how to write a term paper how to write a term paper
Reply Bad Credit
1:49 AM on December 1, 2017 
2500 loan short term loans short loans short term loan lenders not brokers
Reply Paydayloan
9:09 AM on November 30, 2017 
short cash loans short term cash loans short term loans online online cash loans
Reply JamesClots
12:31 AM on November 30, 2017 
writing a paper writing a paper paper writing paper writing my free web cam cam live porn cam live porn webcams porn direct loan lenders direct loan lenders direct lenders of loans direct loan lenders payday advance loan instant online payday loan online payday advance loan payday advance loan direct lender payday loans direct payday loan lenders direct payday loan lenders direct payday lenders online fast payday loan direct lenders online loans online payday loan paydayloans online direct payday loan lenders online payday loan lenders loans online no credit check payday loan companies write essay buy an essay uk essay writing scholarship essay quick cash loans bad credit loans direct lenders payday advance online loan cash
Reply JamesClots
12:36 PM on November 29, 2017 
argument essays college essay college essay college essay help research essay how to write research papers research paper proposal research paper proposal help me on my homework write my research paper write my research paper write my research paper
Reply BosHet
12:31 PM on November 29, 2017 
Готовые комплекты беспроводное видеонаблюдение включают в себя все необходимое оборудование и программное обеспечение
предварительно настроенное нашими специалистами. Основным отличием комплектов данной категории, является использование
в качестве каналов передачи данных, между камерой и роутером, беспроводной Wi-Fi сети.
Reply ivannablist
8:32 PM on November 28, 2017 
партнерская программа по: https://alideals.info/partnerskaya-programma-aliekspress-i-keshbe
k-kakaya-svyaz/
Reply FloyshdDax
5:56 PM on November 28, 2017 
Hello. And Bye.